Skip to content

Blog post

Back to the blog

Your shop rate is somebody else's guess

The rate underneath every quote you send was set once, by somebody, in a year you would not recognise. The gap between it and the truth leaves with every job.

Schedule a Conversation
Financial ControlPain Point Series · Part 12November 18, 2026James Lincoln

A commercial print shop in Springfield, Missouri, a Friday morning, the estimator's desk under the window. A strip of masking tape ran along the bottom of his monitor with a number on it in black marker. Sixty-eight. That was the shop rate, and it had been inside every quote that left the building for years.

I asked who worked it out. He said the tape came with the desk. The owner thought his old partner had done the sums, and the partner had sold his half and left the trade six years back.

The tape had gone yellow at the edges. Rent had gone up twice since somebody wrote on it, the health plan had gone up every year, and there was a digital press on the floor now with a lease payment attached. The number had not moved.

A shop that knows its total and not its parts

Nothing about the place was sloppy. Presses maintained, deliveries on time, seventeen people who knew their work, customers a decade deep. He could tell me what the company earned last year to the dollar, because his accountant told him at the year end.

Under that one figure the picture went dark. Catalog runs, hospital forms, invitation work, wide-format banners, all of it went in as jobs and came back as a single number at year end. He had a feeling about which work was good work. He could not show me.

A feeling like that is right about half the time. You keep selling the job that quietly loses and turning away the one that would have paid, and nothing in the way the money gets counted will ever tell you.

Some of this will sound like your place.

Ask two people to price the same job and you get two numbers, because one works off the sheet and one works off what the customer says he paid last time.

The wage in your estimate is the number on the pay stub. Payroll taxes, workers' comp, the health plan and the paid days nobody produces in sit somewhere else, if they sit anywhere.

The overhead figure buried in your pricing came from a year with a different rent, a different insurance bill and three fewer people.

The machine that earns you the most has a payment against it and no hourly cost. In your estimates it runs for free.

You will turn work around in eighteen hours when nobody else in town will touch it, and that job is priced like a two-week turn.

If your best machine died on a Friday you could not say where the next one comes from.

You could not tell me today, without an afternoon of digging, whether last month's biggest job made money.

The new system asked for a rate and somebody typed sixty-eight

When a shop in this condition calls me, the word pricing rarely comes up. The word is software. The estimating system is fifteen years old, it does not talk to the presses, and a quote takes an hour by hand. Get us something modern and we will finally see where the money goes.

So they go shopping. Thirty to seventy thousand dollars by the time it runs and the staff can use it, plus half a year of somebody's evenings. The install goes fine. Then on about the second day the system asks for hourly rates, and somebody walks to the estimator's desk and reads them off the tape.

A costing system does arithmetic on the numbers you hand it. Give it a rate nobody has checked in a decade and it produces wrong prices faster, in a better font, with your logo on them. The software does buy you one thing worth having. It collects the hours jobs really took. Hardly anybody reads that record, because reading it means accepting the rates were wrong and repricing customers who have been content for years.

Every quote you send is a claim about what an hour costs in your building. Most owners have never gone back to check the claim.

A different error waits on the other side of the software. A man sits with his accountant, builds a properly burdened labor rate, then spreads his overhead evenly across every hour the shop sells. The old two- color press carries the same overhead per hour as the digital that cost six times as much, takes more floor and came with a service contract the old one never needed. So the cheap machine is priced too high and the expensive one too low. You lose the bids you should win and win the bids you should lose. Your sales look healthy. Your bank balance argues.

Twenty-two dollars, five thousand four hundred times

We rebuilt one rate on a legal pad, the two-color press, and it landed at ninety dollars an hour before a cent of profit. The operator's wage went in with twenty-seven cents added to every dollar of it, which is where payroll taxes, workers' comp and benefits land. Then the machine's own cost of lease, service contract, power, plates and wash. Then a monthly amount set aside toward the press that replaces this one, priced at what one costs today, not what the books carry the old one at. Then its share of rent, insurance and the front office. Ninety against the sixty-eight on the tape.

The shop sold about five thousand four hundred production hours last year, and every one of them was quoted off that strip of tape. The other machines came out short as well, by eighteen to thirty-one dollars. Hold the gap flat at twenty-two and it is a hundred and eighteen thousand eight hundred dollars of margin that was never in a price.

He did not have a sales problem. Work came in, the floor ran six days in a good stretch, and his customers stayed. What the company could not do was pay for itself. There was never money for the next press, never enough to move a good operator's pay before somebody across town moved it, never a quarter of cushion for a slow stretch. Every job came back with less than it cost to be able to do the job. That is an account that will not grow no matter how hard the floor works, and it is why selling harder here leaves a shop busier and poorer.

Take the tape off the monitor

Monday morning, before anybody prices anything, pull the number. Peel the tape off the monitor, delete the cell, take the page out of the binder, and put it in a drawer where you can find it again. For five working days nothing leaves the building priced off that rate.

Every quote gets three lines on the back instead. Labor is the hours times the wage times 1.27, which covers taxes, comp and benefits. Machine is the hours times what that machine costs to own for an hour. Materials are what you paid the last time you bought them, not the number in the price book.

Things will break. The breaks are what you came for. Somebody will be at your door inside a day asking what the press costs an hour, and nobody will be able to answer him. Hang a clipboard by the estimating desk and write the question on it. By Wednesday there will be four or five more. Does an operator waiting on plates count as press time. Do we bill the two hours a week we spend fixing customer files. Why does the eighteen-hour job cost the same as the two-week one.

That clipboard is the output of the week. The quotes are not.

Friday, take the two questions that came up most and answer them. Burdened labor is last year's total payroll cost, wages and taxes and comp and benefits, divided by the hours your people worked rather than the hours you paid for. Strip out vacation, sick days, paid days off, training and the hours the floor stood waiting. Owners who have never looked find it sits about a third above the wage they were using.

Machine cost is the payment or lease, the service contract, power, consumables and a monthly amount toward the machine that replaces this one, divided by the hours it ran last year. Use the run hours off the counter. Available hours flatter you and put you back where you started.

Two answers is enough to rebuild your rate in an afternoon. Get neither, put the tape back, and at least the number on it is a decision you made rather than one you inherited.

The quotes you stop arguing about

Six weeks out, watch for what stops. The pause before you say a price stops. Your estimator stops carrying quotes in to ask whether the number is too high. The Friday argument about taking a job nobody in the room feels good about stops, because everyone can see where the number came from.

What starts is quieter. You lose a job and it does not ruin the afternoon. Somebody wants it Tuesday and you charge him for Tuesday. Two customers left that shop inside four months, both on the short list the owner had always suspected. Revenue came down a few percent. What was left at the end came up.

He kept the tape. It sits in his drawer with a card behind it showing four rebuilt rates, because he wanted to see the difference. The work in that shop was always good. The number underneath it was a guess somebody wrote in marker in a better year and left behind. Owners talk about pricing as a question of nerve, whether you have the stomach to charge more. Mostly it is arithmetic nobody did. Arithmetic is easier to fix than nerve.

Cost Knowledge and Pricing is seven statements in the Business Check-in, and this article works through most of them. The ones left over ask what else in your building has never been priced, and the check-in is free and takes about ten minutes.

Related reading

Start the conversation

Reading about it is the easy part.

Thirty minutes with somebody who has made the same call before. Bring the decision the last post made you think about.

A hand picking up a fountain pen resting on a marble desk in warm light, in black and white.